On a scale of 1-10
[I rate an album by how much I like it, but it's position on my top 25 list is determined by how cohesive/listenable it is, and how strong of a release it is]25.
Monsters of Folk - Monsters of FolkI had such high expectations from the self-titled debut album by indie/folk supergroup, Monsters of Folk. Much to my dismay, the album sounded less like the collaboration of four of our generations' most prolific songwriters and more like a b-sides compilation from their respective bands.
3 out of 1024.
Dead Man's Bones - Dead Man's BonesNot long ago, while watching Lars & The Real Girl, I found myself thinking that I would like to hear Ryan Gosling do a music project. In the movie, there is a small part where he is singing with a sweet, yet intense vibrato that harkened back to the likes of Bing Crosby and Fred Astaire. Much to my surprise (and none to my disappointment), Mr. Gosling did indeed start a band, and it is something to behold. Very reminiscent of the creepy type music that you would hear on a halloween cd,
Dead Man's Bones is stripped down and hauntingly beautiful.
6 out of 1023.
White Rabbits - It's FrighteningWhite Rabbits have something going for them: not too many other bands sound like them. Their sound is theirs and theirs alone and they do it very well. Though they are not a band that I would rush out to buy tickets to see, they are certainly a welcome addition to my list.
5 out of 1022.
Grizzly Bear - VeckatimestWell 2009 seems to be the year for Grizzly Bear.
Veckatimest was on the top of a great deal many "Most Anticipated" album lists, and it is certainly a great album. Personally, a little of them goes a long way, but that's not to say that they are bad. I appreciate this album for what it is and would be remiss if I were to leave it off of my list.
4 out of 1021.
Passion Pit - MannersThis band seems to be topping "best of" lists everywhere, and they came from seemingly nowhere. All of the sudden, this band (consisting of a drummer, a few keyboard players, and a dancing singer) came out and blew everyone away. Dancy and fun, it is small wonder why. Here's to hoping that a sophomore release is as strong and that they are more than just a flash in the pan
7 out of 1020.
mewithoutYou - It's All Crazy! It's All False! It's All A Dream! It's Alright!2009 saw beloved post-punk rockers mewithoutYou head even more in a different direction than ever before. Their newest offering is far from where they began with
A to B: Life, and is even a departure from the sound of
Brother, Sister (my personal favorite), which was their most experimental to date. Seeing them this summer, though, was proof enough for me that they are still full of the intense passion that they are best known for.
6 out of 1019.
The Flaming Lips - EmbryonicAll that I can say is that it is about time that The Flaming Lips came out with a new album. It would be hard for anyone to listen to
Yoshimi Battles The Pink Robots or
War Of The Mystics and not fall in love. The same is true of
Embryonic. Great album.
7 out of 1018.
Conor Oberst and The Mystic Valley Band - Outer SouthIt's hard for me to enjoy Oberst's solo work even a fraction of how much I enjoy Bright Eyes (especially
Cassadaga and
I'm Wide Awake), but this album is enjoyable none the less.
5 out of 1017.
Dignan - Cheaters & ThievesDignan is a band that I have seen grow and change over the last couple of years. They started as my buddy Eric's friend's band that I enjoyed as well, to one of the bands that I am anticipating to blow up any day now.
Cheaters & Thieves is certainly proof of that: one listen to the track "Charlatan" and you'll be sold.
8 out of 1016.
Phoenix - Wolfgang Amadeus PhoenixIndie-pop darlings Phoenix are back, and how.
Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix is more than just a fun album, it's brilliant. I would go so far as to say that they are too good at what they do.
8 out of 1015.
Ben Kweller - Changing HorsesWho would have thought a] that Ben Kweller would write a country album and b] that it would be amazing? Not me, that's for sure. Previous to
Horses, I wouldn't have counted myself even the least of Kweller fans, and now I can honestly say that I am thoroughly impressed.
8 out of 1014.
The Cave Singers - Welcome JoyI don't know that I can necessarily or accurately describe what it is that captivates me so much about The Cave Singers, but there is something that draws me to them so much, especially
Welcome Joy.
8 out of 1013.
Other Lives - Other LivesOther Lives is a relatively new find for me, but it is safe to say that we will be hearing a good deal from this band over the coming years. I would not be surprised at all to see them attaining the same level of fame that bands like Fleet Foxes now enjoy.
7 out of 1012.
Arctic Monkeys - HumbugArctic Monkeys is a band that can take a little to get into at first, but once you're in, you're in.
Humbug is an incredible album, but far from my favorite. Personally, I would like to see them return to the sound that made them famous on
Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not.
7 out of 1011.
Bob Dylan - Together Through LifeDylan's newest album is much more based in blues than anything else in his compendium. It is also a great album.
7 out of 1010.
M. Ward - Hold TimeOh how I love the "him" when he is sans the "she". M. Ward is far too competent of a musician and songwriter to step out of the center for anyone else. His songs are honest and beautiful, sung and told like no one else I've ever heard.
8 out of 109.
Wilco - Wilco (The Album)A great album from one of my all-time favorite bands. Initially, it took a little to get in to. Personally, I would like to see the band return to a
Ghost Is Born type sound, but I am by no means disappointed by where they are.
8 out of 108.
Ben Gibbard & Jay Farrar - One Fast Move Or I'm Gone: Kerouac's Big SurBen Gibbard of Death Cab For Cutie fame is one of my favorite songwriters. Jay Farrar is one of my least favorites. Somehow, the two, rather than landing in some mediocre territory, managed to write one of best albums of the year, paying homage to and at times quoting one of my favorite authors.
8 out of 107.
The Avett Brothers - I And Love And YouPrevious to the release of
I And Love And You, I could easily say that I was less than impressed with The Avett Brothers. Since then, however, I have found that I am a big fan of
Emotionalism as well. A great band that isn't easily understood at first.
7 out of 106.
David Bazan - Curse Your BranchesI have been a big Pedro The Lion fan for nearly 7 years now and I was lucky enough to see them twice before they disbanded. Finally, 2009 saw Bazan's first proper LP since leaving Pedro behind and it is very very good. The one disconnect for me is how produced the album is, but that takes little away from it on the whole.
9 out of 105.
J. Tillman - Vacilando Territory BluesWhen I heard J. Tillman's album
Cancer and Delirium, I officially hated him. I thought that the songs were boring and trite even. The only reason that I even listened to
Vacilando Territory Blues was out of hope that it would be significantly better, if not to see why people were still paying attention to him. It was then that I discovered that he is the drummer for Fleet Foxes. This, of course, peaked my interest. Suffice it to say,
Vacilando is better by leaps and bounds, landing it in the top 5 of 2009.
9 out of 104.
Mumford & Sons - Sigh No MoreTo say that Mumford & Sons is a good band is like saying that The Office is an alright television show. This lesser-known british band has written one of the best indie/folk albums I have ever heard. Much like Passion Pit, I hope that their next album can live up to the standards that their debut set.
9 out of 103.
Pomegranates - Everybody, Come Outside!I find myself listening more to folk bands than indie/rock bands, but Pomegranates are the perfect blend of dance beats and indie/pop to get you dancing, even if it's just by yourself in the car. This band puts on one of the best live shows I have ever seen and have written easily one of the best and most cohesive indie/pop records that I have ever heard.
10 out of 102.
Portugal. The Man - The Satanic SatanistI remember back when Portugal. The Man first came out. They were a young prog/rock band that was doing a watered-down version of what The Mars Volta became famous for. Then, somewhere along the line, they started writing the sort of songs that make
The Satanic Satanist so incredible. Easily one of the best albums I have ever heard.
10 out of 101.
A.A. Bondy - When The Devil's LooseA.A. Bondy is without question one of the best songwriters of my generation, and the release of
When The Devil's Loose is proof that he is more than a flash in the pan. The songs are beautiful and organic and hopeful. It is the type of music that you can imagine listening to while you're drinking a cup of coffee and reading a newspaper in the early hours of the morning, before the world is totally awake and before you begin another day.
10 out of 10So that's my top 25 of 2009. Feel free to agree or disagree. I would love to hear what your top 25 is.
As always, if you have any requests, let me know. I'll see what I can do to fulfill them.